Man United vs. Man City: Who Will Win the Race for Carlos Baleba?

Muhe - Friday, 08 August 2025 | 04:00 PM (WIB)

Man United vs. Man City: Who Will Win the Race for Carlos Baleba?

90 MIN FOOTBALL - The summer transfer market is heating up again with the rivalry between the two Manchester giants. This time, the name of Brighton's young midfielder, Carlos Baleba, is being contested. At just 21 years old, Baleba is considered to have great potential to fill the void in the midfield of both clubs. So, why is this Cameroonian so sought after, and what makes him an ideal target for Manchester United and Manchester City?

Carlos Baleba: The Heart of Brighton's Defense

Since joining from Lille in 2023, Carlos Baleba has quickly become one of the most promising defensive midfielders in the Premier League. His energetic playing style, strong physicality, and comfort on the ball have made him a standout in the Brighton squad.Adept Ball Winner: Baleba possesses an uncanny ability to intercept opponents and win possession. His strong physique allows him to dominate the midfield.Composure in Possession: Although predominantly a defensive midfielder, he also possesses accurate passing and composure under pressure, making him an ideal player in the modern game system.Long-Term Potential: At his young age, Baleba displays maturity and tactical intelligence beyond his years, making him a valuable long-term investment.

Why Man United and Man City Are Competing for Him

The interest from both Manchester clubs demonstrates Baleba's high value. Both have specific needs in midfield that he could fill.Manchester United: The Red Devils have long been searching for a solid defensive midfielder to anchor their defense. Baleba's arrival would provide much-needed physical presence and defensive prowess, while also providing backup and rotation options for Kobbie Mainoo.Manchester City: Under Pep Guardiola, City are always looking for a versatile midfielder who can adapt to their system. Baleba possesses similar attributes to Rodri, namely strong defensive abilities and precise passing. City see him as the ideal successor to maintain their dominance in midfield for years to come.

Negotiation Challenges

Although interest from both clubs is very real, this transfer process will not be easy. Brighton are known to be tough negotiators and will not let their star players go cheaply. With a contract that runs until 2028, Brighton has a very strong bargaining position. Furthermore, Baleba himself is reportedly still comfortable at the south coast club and is in no rush to leave.The interest from Manchester United and Manchester City in Carlos Baleba is clear evidence of his talent. While his transfer fee may be record-breaking, his ability and potential are believed to be worth the investment. This transfer war will be one of the most intriguing sagas of the summer transfer window.Currently, only Manchester United are reported to have made initial contact through intermediaries, while City's interest remains at an observational level. Negotiations are expected to be extremely difficult, as Brighton are reportedly demanding a hefty price tag of over £100 million.***